The cheeky article in question is found here on Kyoko Shimbun ('Fabricated News'). The gist of it is that a manuscript of Sei Shonogan is recently discovered and in it the great Japanese court lady/diarist opines that 'men who moe Murasaki-no-Ue is very unbecoming'. It is, the article purports, the first use of moe in the meaning which is now widely used in present-day subcultures.
For those of you who have not read Genji Monogatari - Murasaki-no-Ue is a lady who was raised from childhood to be Prince Genji's dream woman and actually does grow up to be his dream woman. (It's more complicated than this but you get the idea.) I suppose you may read the purported criticism from Sei Shonagon as:
- a criticism of Heian gentlemen being obsessed with a fictional (ie. unreal) female character in Genji Monogatari; or
- a criticism of their obsession with prepubescent/teenage girls.
I think the former interpretation is more likely than the latter in this context, though either way it is a subtle commentary on today's gal-game/eroge and moe anime subcultures. However, I think there is a key difference between the obsession with prepubescent/teenage girls then and now: Prince Genji is interested in the potential of young Murasaki growing into a beautiful and refined woman of his dreams, but now many male anime fans into gal-game/eroge are interested into the grown version of the dream girl? Prince Genji is interested young Murasaki in what she will be, but it seems to me that most fans of gal-game/eroge are interested in the dream girl only as so far as she remains the way she is at that particular age - it is as though if she grows up, the magic will somehow be gone.
To be fair, my personal opinion is that Murasaki-no-Ue is a woman's vision of the ideal woman than a man's vision per se
(she is a female character created by a woman for the consumption of
women after all). But then it's not like I have an X-ray vision into
the minds of men past and present.
That is all I have to say for now. Ladies and gentlemen - the floor is all yours to have your say.
Recent Comments